Many reviewers, one good version.

You sent a landing page, newsletter or proposal to five people. Now you have five sets of notes, and some of them disagree. Here is a simple way to turn them into one version you are happy to publish, with any tool.

Why five reviewers make it harder before they make it better.

Each reviewer reads with their own job in mind. Your co-founder wants it bolder, a colleague wants it shorter, and a friend in sales wants the price higher up. Each note can be right on its own and still pull against the others.

The trouble starts when it all lands in one place. Two people rewrite the same sentence in different directions, someone edits a line another person already changed, and you end up trying to remember who wanted what.

More readers do make a better text in the end. They need a little structure first, and most of it happens before anyone opens your draft.

Ask each reviewer one clear question.

A loose “any thoughts?” gets you everything at once: typos, taste and a rewrite of your opening. A specific question gets answers you can use.

Ask your designer whether the headline fits the page. Ask a customer whether the offer is clear in the first two lines. Ask your editor which paragraph could go.

You will still get notes outside the question, and that is fine. The question tells each person where to start, and later it tells you which notes to weigh most.

Let each person's changes stay their own.

When reviewers edit the same copy, they start reacting to each other. The second tidies the first person's change, the third agrees with whoever went last, and your own idea drifts away.

So give each reviewer a clean starting point. In Microsoft Word, send each person their own copy with tracked changes on. In Google Docs, make a copy per reviewer and ask them to use suggesting mode. Both tools are familiar and keep every change and comment in place, and for one or two readers a single shared file is often all you need.

With five, the shared file is where it gets hard. Everyone's changes interleave in one stream, and you accept or reject them one at a time without seeing how any one person's version would read. Separate copies solve that, at the cost of some juggling.

Look at each person's version before you decide.

Before you accept a single change, read each reviewer's version from top to bottom, as if it were final. A change that looks odd alone often makes sense in context, and a clever line can break the paragraph around it.

Keep short notes as you go: what this person improved, what they missed, where they disagree with someone else. By the end you know who had the best opening, who caught the real problem, and where two people want opposite things. Those disagreements are yours to settle, so write them down and settle them on purpose.

Mix the best parts and say what changed.

Now build your version. Start from your own draft and bring in changes person by person, beginning with the reviewer you agreed with most. Where two people changed the same words, pick one wording and move on.

Notes without wording, like “love this part” or “feels long”, are easy to lose. Treat them as signals, and change the text yourself where you agree.

Then tell your reviewers what you did, in a few lines: what you took, what you left, and why. People who see their notes were read are glad to review the next draft, and everyone ends up looking at the same final version.

How Draftland does it.

Draftland is built around these steps. You send one link. Reviewers open it in their browser with no account and nothing to install, and each person's notes become their own version of your text.

Your draft stays one version. A bar at the top shows each reviewer as a coloured chip with their initial and name. Hover a person to see your whole text with their changes in it; move away and it goes back. Click a person to add them to your mix, then click more people to mix in their changes. You can also take a single change from someone.

Changed words carry that person's colour. Wording the built-in AI prepared from a reviewer's comment looks paler, so you always see what the reviewer wrote and what was prepared from their note. Where two people changed the same words, the later pick wins, a short line tells you, and one click switches back to the other wording. Praise and general remarks sit as small dots beside the passage and never change your text unless you ask.

When the mix reads right, you put the changes into your draft in one step, and you can undo it.

It works with Word and Google Docs too. Bring a Word file, or a Google Doc downloaded as Word, with its comments, and each reviewer's comments become their own version. Export back to Word, plain text or Markdown. There are more examples for content creators and for founders and makers.

Try it on the next draft you send out.

Pick a real draft that is about to go to more than two people and send one link. Draftland is free to start, and reviewers never pay. See pricing for the details.

Try it free

Microsoft Word and Google Docs are trademarks of their owners. Draftland is not affiliated with them.